Skip to main content

Is Social Studies Fiction A Better Name for Women’s Fiction?

 The manuscript I’m working on is becoming less and less like a romance, and more like a contemporary about healing/friendship/different types of love, with suspense and a romantic subplot. I’m really stuck on what to call it as I don’t like the term ‘women’s fiction’… 

Ideas?

Here’s the mood board I made… 



Why don’t I like the term ‘Women’s Fiction’? 

Well, it doesn’t really tell you much about the genre. It seems kind of sexist, like women have to have their own classification especially for them, and there’s no genre for ‘men’s fiction’—which, to me, kind of implies that (almost all?) other genres are written primarily with men in mind, and all stories for women just get put into this one category? 

Like, it also means men likely won’t read women’s fiction for fear of being seen as feminine … so why class a whole genre of books as being just for women? What is it about them that mean men shouldn’t read them? Are these stories deemed too emotional and weak? Too trashy? I know romance is often considered trashy, which is a huge problem, and it’s considered a female genre. So why do we have to have a second genre that’s just for women that many men will look down upon too and avoid? 

Women can read stereotypically male genres but men can’t read ours? 

And this isn’t to say that the things that pop up in women’s fiction aren’t available in men’s fiction—because they are! 

Randy Susan Meyers writes, “If I’m not mistaken, are there not many books written by men and marketed to all genders that include abuse, poverty, divorce, familial breakdown, and other social struggles? Philip Roth, John Updike, Jonathan Tropper, Jonathan Franzen, Jeffrey Eugenides, Pat Conroy, and Wally Lamb – to name a few. The prejudice is clear, but there is also a practical problem here. If ‘women’s fiction’ is a marketing device, it’s confusing as thus. Label a novel ‘women’s fiction’ — is the message ‘not for men’? By carving and dicing books into thin-as-lox slices, women writers lose readership. With ‘women’s fiction’ are half the potential readers in the world blocked off before the books hit the shelves?” 

I really don’t like the term ‘women’s fiction’, yet there’s not really an alternative for stories that focus on the social issues and people and families, especially when they’re written by women. If they’re by men, they’re often referred to as literary or classics, and yes, some women’s books will get classed as literary and classics too, but overwhelmingly they’re put into the women’s fiction category. They’re othered.

I think ‘social studies fiction’ would be a much better name for the genre—and that it should include both the books written for men and women and by men and women. (And of course non-binary and agender people too—in short, any books by anyone about social issues or struggles—because of course another way in which the current term of ‘women’s fiction’ is damaging is through equating it with gender, suggesting a gender binary.) 

Even just thinking of the name Social Studies Fiction (or social struggles fiction?) while writing this blog post has helped me a lot. I feel focused again, and I feel like it’s better describing what my current manuscript is. Maybe I’ll come back to this post at a later point to add more musings on this… 

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Out Now: IN MY DREAMS, My Ace Romance!

  IN MY DREAMS is out now! I can't believe my first ace romance is out in the world!  Writing  In My Dreams   was such a special process for me. I am asexual, and for so long, I believed that any romance novel I wrote would have to include allosexual characters. I didn't think anyone would want to read about a main character who's asexual, especially if it was a romance novel. I really believed that a romance novel had to include sex--but all I really wanted to write was the romance (because that's what appeals to me). You know, those scenes where your characters are falling in love, where everything's new and exciting, where you're really emotionally invested in a pairing.  And where there's also no sexual attraction.   Because that's what it's like for me. I'm asexual, and I don't experience sexual attraction or have a desire for sex. I'm still attracted to people (physically and emotionally), and I'm still very romantic (though man

I wrote an Ace Romance!

 Oh my goodness, I almost can't believe it! My first ace romance releases in less than a week!  Writing this book has been amazing--and so, so validating for my own identity.  I'm asexual, and I'm a romance writer. When I begun my romance-writing journey, I firmly believed I'd have to write about sex. I mean, I started with my Rose Haven series (the prequel, When We Were Young, is out now, with book one following next year), and while I love those characters, I always felt a bit 'stuck' when it came to writing the sexual chemistry and the sex scenes. Because, well, I haven't experienced those feelings. I don't understand sexual desire. I've never looked at someone and felt sexually attracted to them.  I realised I was ace (asexual) in my mid-teens. I'm now in my mid-20s, and this hasn't changed. At first, I kept my asexuality a guarded secret. I didn't know how people would react. I'd had therapists suggest I was broken, and friends s

Introducing WHEN WE WERE YOUNG!

I'm so excited to announce that my first short story will be releasing on October 29th, 2019! Introducing When We Were Young :  It's been eight years since Emma last saw Oscar, the love of her life. Eight years since their messy breakup. She never wanted to see him again and relive that pain, but then she finds his photo album among her boxes of college things. Oscar never met his parents. They died the day he was born, and the only connection he has to them is through the photo album his grandmother gave him. A photo album he thought he'd never see again. When Emma returns the photo album to him, Oscar discovers it's not just the album that's been missing from his life for the last eight years. But can Emma ever forgive him for what he did? When We Were Young  is a snack-sized read about young love and second chances. This is a short read--perfect for reading during a break time--and I can't wait to share it with you!  When We Were Young is